She did an online search and found that others have gone before her in making their own homemade toaster pastries, so she printed a dough recipe found on SmittenKitchen.com and set to work. It's basically a 2-crust pie crust recipe with an egg added for better handling...So the crust is not too delicate for eating by hand.


After cooling, she spread it on rectangles of dough, rolled about 1/8" thick, keeping the filling about a half inch in from all edges. Another rectangle of dough went over the filling and she pressed the edges together, then used fork tines to seal the edges further, and pricked holes in the top of the pastries.

These got baked at 350 degrees for 25 to 30 minutes. She iced some of them with a powdered sugar, vanilla, and water glaze...I prefer mine without the unnecessary sugar load.

These are delicious. The crust is flaky, without being crumbly. The filling was very fruity, and not overly sweet. I am not a fan of Pop Tarts, but I could eat these all day.


Happily shared on The Better Half's weekly DIY share party.